I knew I was in trouble this morning when my arms were too tired to even finish putting on my mascara. Who stops to take a breather during mascara application?

Want to save this recipe?
Just drop your email here and I’ll send it right away! Plus you’ll get new recipes from me every week. Yes please!

Weaklings, that’s who. I went running with a friend this morning. Let me revise that. I went running while she did cartwheels and back flips in my vicinity. We were going about the same speed.

Then the rest of the day my body kept reminding me that I am a complete wuss, because I kept being tempted to do things like sit down in the shower from exhaustion, or stop smiling so wide because it hurt my face. Seriously, who gets tired cheek muscles from a casual morning run?

So I know these little dudes might not look very special, but they definitely pack a punch. There are only 3 ingredients, and they take about 3 minutes to make, so they are an awesome last-minute treat. My mom is locally famous for making these. She has been making them since she was 12 years old, when her parents gave her her first cook book. I grew up eating these.

Wheaties Treats are perfect for mailing. They are completely non-perishable, and they can’t get demolished en route. Don’t even bother refrigerating them. Just scoop into a ziplock bag, seal, and send. The recipient can divide and refrigerate as desired. My mom sent me these in college all the time. And it was awesome. Thanks Mom!

If you are still dubious about these, take my 16-month-old daughter’s word for it. I was out on our porch taking pictures of these and I turned around to see her licking the screen door, watching me jealously.

***P.S. Come back next week for my first giveaway on Monday, June 18th!!***

Butterscotch Peanut Butter Wheaties Treats

Source: my mom Janice who revised it from the Let’s Start to Cook Farm Journal

11 ounce package butterscotch chips
1/2 cup peanut butter
6 cups Wheaties, or similar generic brand

melt chips. add pb. add wheaties. freeze.

Those are my mom’s original directions. Pretty straightforward. But for those who like detail, I’ll give you this:

Place the butterscotch chips in a very large bowl. Melt in the microwave, stirring every 1 minute. When chips are completely melted, add the peanut butter and stir to combine. Add the Wheaties and stir until all the cereal is coated. Spread on a cookie sheet and refrigerate or freeze uncovered for about a half hour. At this point, cut them into bars (or any cookie-cutter shape you like) and return to the fridge or freezer until they are the coldness level you like. I actually prefer mine room temperature.

Categorized as , ,

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

You May Also Like...


  1. I am super excited right now. Mercedes boyfriend has never had these before, so we are rectifying that tonight! I only make these now and then because one, I could eat the whole batch and two, Wheaties cost like $6 freaking a box right now!

    1. My mom made a ton of these for Nate’s farewell party a couple weeks ago and we were all just reveling in the nostalgia 😂 so good! And I know, cereal prices are nuts right??

  2. It’s true. Wheaties cookies=happiness. I’m not sure there is any simpler equation, or one more true. I never make these because I could probably eat my whole weight in Wheaties cookies, or at least an entire batch. I relegate myself to the “smaller” portions mom sends in the mail. (Adam gets about one cookie’s worth, I usually eat the rest. No joke, ask him.)

  3. yes, sarah, i grew up eating the breakfast of champions – i always thought corn flakes tasted funny, and were wimpy in cereal to boot. hence my wheaties substitution in these cookies in my youth :) i also tried to tell myself that wheaties made the cookies more healthy…can i tell you that i almost always keep these ingredients on hand, just in case i feel one of my children needs some happiness in their life?!!

  4. There were WHEATIES in those things? You mean that gallon ziploc full of awesome clumps of goodness was made of the breakfast of champions??? Unfathomable.
    I have to admit, I would feel weird eating these without sticking Easter egg cling-ons to my window or attempting to hang a St. Patrick’s Day door decoration. But that’s just Janice-related college nostalgia talking.

    1. You never knew? I love that you never bothered to ask. I should have told you it was pork rinds or doritos or something.

  5. I need to make these and send them to Jessie. She is peanut-butter lover! Great recipe Karen.
    Was Charlotte REALLY licking the screen door, or are you perhaps, exaggerating just a little . . .

    1. Yes, she really was licking the screen door. I may be exaggerating that fact’s correlation to these Wheaties Treats, but the screen door was definitely licked!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.